From Lp2 Wiki
- Albert Belle / Henry Rodriguez, Sante Fe Gamblers - 1999 A.
- Johnny Bench, Phoenix Faith Twains - 1999 B.
- Will Clark, MoJo JoJo's - 2000 A.
- Ty Cobb / Barry Bonds, Evansville Pimps / Ilion Bombers - 2000 B.
- Tris Speaker, Wu-Tang Venoms - 2001 A.
- Lou Gehrig, Los Angeles Kings - 2001 B.
- Derek Lowe, Florida Christians - 2002 A.
- Nomar Garciaparra, Ybor City Rollers - 2002 B.
- Babe Ruth, Florida Christians - 2003 A.
- Lou Gehrig, Beantown Monstahs - 2003 B.
- George Sisler, Finger Lakes Flashes - 2004 A.
- Mickey Mantle, Ybor City Rollers - 2004 B.
- Jason Bay, Sante Fe Gamblers - 2005 A.
- Carl Yastrzemski, San Benito Strangegloves - 2006.
